Call Us Now
Email Us Now
Can Alternative Sentencing Help You Avoid Jail Time and Other Severe Consequences of a Florida Theft Charge?
In Florida, the judicial system provides several alternatives to incarceration for theft offenses, which can be particularly relevant for first-time offenders or those involved in lesser degrees of theft. These alternatives are designed to offer rehabilitation opportunities or to mitigate the harshness of traditional jail sentences. The availability and specific requirements of these sentencing options can vary by county in Florida. Working with an experienced Lakeland theft defense attorney is crucial for understanding the options open to you.
What are the Eligibility Requirements for Sentencing Alternatives?
Only some offenders will be eligible for alternative sentencing for their theft charges. Alternative sentencing options are considered based on several factors, including the severity of the offense, the value of the stolen property, the offender’s criminal history, and the circumstances surrounding the crime. For instance, thefts involving higher values or additional criminal activities might not qualify for these lighter sentences and, instead, could result in more severe penalties such as imprisonment. Judges have the discretion to decide the most appropriate sentence based on the offender’s profile and the case’s specifics, aiming to balance the goals of punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, and public safety.
Probation
Probation is a common alternative to jail time, allowing the offender to live in the community under the restrictions outlined by the court. The terms of an individual’s probation often include maintaining employment, attending counseling, paying fines or restitution, and avoiding further legal trouble. Violating the terms of probation can result in severe penalties, including serving the original jail or prison sentence.
Standard probation is the basic form of probation where the offender must regularly report to a probation officer and adhere to the terms of their release. Administrative probation is a more lenient form where the offender does not have to report to a probation officer regularly but must still comply with the standard probation conditions. Probation is frequently used for first-time offenders or those committing minor theft offenses.
House Arrest
House arrest, referred to as “community control” under Florida Statute § 948.001(3), is another sentencing alternative where the offender is confined to their community, home, or a non-institutional residential placement instead of jail. Participants must fill out weekly schedules and daily logs and are often subject to curfews, drug and alcohol testing, and restrictions on contact with certain individuals.
The offender may be allowed to leave their location for pre-approved essential tasks such as work, school, or medical appointments. However, individuals on house arrest are closely monitored, typically through electronic ankle bracelets, to ensure they comply with the terms of their home confinement. House arrest is generally reserved for non-violent offenders, as the state imposes strict eligibility criteria. Violating the terms of house arrest can result in the original sentence being reinstated, including potential incarceration.
Diversion Programs
Diversion programs are particularly aimed at first-time offenders, who are given the opportunity to participate in specific programs instead of serving time in jail. Individuals with no more than one previous conviction for a non-violent misdemeanor may also be eligible in some counties. Sometimes, the victim’s consent may be required for the defendant to participate in a diversion program. Participation in a diversion program is often subject to the approval of the State Attorney’s Office or the prosecutor handling the case.
Successful completion of such programs often results in the charges being dropped or reduced. Elements of a diversion program may include theft education programs, community service, or restitution to the victims. The specific eligibility criteria can vary by county and judicial circuit in Florida, so working closely with an experienced criminal defense attorney is crucial to navigating the options and increasing your chances of qualifying for a diversion program.
Misdemeanor Intervention Program (MIP)
The MIP program is for first-time offenders and is typically limited to cases involving misdemeanor theft, shoplifting, or petit theft of property under $750 in value. It usually lasts three to six months and may include requirements such as restitution, an anti-shoplifting course, community service, and staying out of trouble. Successful completion can result in the charges being dismissed.
Felony Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) Program
Felony theft cases, especially those involving higher-value stolen property, may be eligible for more intensive felony diversion programs. The PTI program is for first-time offenders charged with third-degree felony theft. It is more involved, expensive, and time-consuming than the MIP, involving supervision by the Florida Department of Corrections. Completing the program can allow the defendant to avoid a criminal conviction.
Informal Diversions
The MIP and PTI programs are examples of formal diversion programs where participants are under court supervision. While these programs provide an alternative to traditional sentencing for eligible defendants, they may not be the best option for some individuals. For example, those with professional licenses may not wish to participate in these formal diversion programs because the offense may still appear on an official criminal record search.
For these individuals, some form of informal diversion may be the ideal outcome. An informal diversion is an agreement that involves the defendant performing approved actions, such as participating in community service or paying restitution to the victim, in exchange for the prosecution dropping the charges. When the charges are dropped outright, they will not endanger the individual’s job or professional licensing. As informal diversions are granted at the discretion of the prosecution, it can be crucial to enlist the services of an experienced defense attorney who can advocate for this outcome on your behalf.
How Can Our Firm Assist You?
If you meet the necessary criteria, sentencing alternatives can help you avoid some of the harsher penalties for a Florida theft charge. A defense attorney from DeMichael Law can examine your case to determine your eligibility. Prosecutors may hesitate to offer alternative sentencing, but a skilled criminal defense attorney can negotiate and fight for a positive resolution. If you’ve been charged with theft, contact our office today at 863-216-1831 for a free case evaluation.
